Score: 8

"Comic"

submission: Star Wars: Old Wounds

date: April 25, 2008

So it was a really good flash, I liked the graphics, the voiceacting was so-so but it's a lot better than I could ever do. As a note to viewers, this is a comic by the same name, it says based on right at the top so any questions of why things were the way they are shouldn't be directed at this animator. Anyways great flash, it would be amazing to see a bunch of stuff taken from comics to be animated.

Score: 9

"Traurig Sontag!"

submission: Dancing Doctor

date: March 1, 2008

So this get's a 9 from me just because you used Traurig Sontag for the opening before it's all techno. Which just happens to be my favorite song of all time. So yay you win!

Score: 6

"buggy"

submission: Sonic Smash Brothers BETA

date: February 29, 2008

So I think it's a really good idea for a game and if you can get it working then it could become the next great classic game. I saw that the players are kind of built on platforms or boxes when fighting, like if i get hit hard and fly to the left i'll only go there like 5 feet before i hit an invisible wall. This makes it impossible to die unless you fly so far up that you die, making the matches really really long. Hope you can sort all this out for when you do this game will be great.

Score: 9

"Nice"

submission: FAWT 3 (Starting Over)

date: February 28, 2008

So I compose classical for The University of Michigan orchestra and I know that if they played this they would love it. The only thing that kept it from a ten for me was the intrumentation was a little techno for me, but if you changed that and added all stardard classical instruments then this would be an amazing piece.